LOOKSMITH

Notes

Sephora Virtual Artist review: what it shows you and what it does not

Last updated:

Sephora Virtual Artist tries on one shade from Sephora's shelves live on camera, and leaves you with nothing but a screenshot to keep.

Sephora Virtual Artist tries on one shade from Sephora's shelves live on camera, and leaves you with nothing but a screenshot to keep. Sephora launched it on 2 February 2016 inside the Sephora to Go app, built on facial-mapping technology from ModiFace, and it does one job well: telling you whether a lipstick Sephora stocks suits you before you carry it to the register.

What Sephora Virtual Artist actually is

Sephora Virtual Artist is a camera feature inside the Sephora app. Point your phone at your own face and it tracks your features in real time, then paints a chosen shade onto the live video. Sephora's own launch release described try-on of "over 3,000 lip colors" with a "3D Live view that moves with them like a mirror."

A year later Sephora added eyeshadow try-on, letting you place up to three shades across the lid, crease and outer corner at once, alongside a small set of preset Expert Looks and step-by-step video tutorials for brows, contouring and highlighting, according to its March 2017 release. A few months after that, Sephora added a colour-match tool: photograph any product, and its June 2017 release says it returns "instant, relevant color matches" from Sephora's own shelves.

None of that is a new idea. It is the same pattern every branded try-on runs: a face mesh, a colour overlay, redrawn thirty-odd times a second, on your own device.

What it is good at

Trying a shade Sephora sells, in real time, for free, on the exact product you are deciding whether to buy there. That is a narrow claim and it is a true one. The live view does not drift far from what a mirror shows you, because it is your own moving face under whatever light you happen to be standing in, and the shade comes from Sephora's own product data rather than a guess.

Does trying on a shade add it to my Sephora basket?

Yes, and this is the part a review fixated on the camera trick misses. Sephora built Virtual Artist to sit next to a real product page, so a shade you like goes straight into your favourites or your basket without leaving the try-on screen. That is a genuine strength over a tool with no store behind it: the try-on and the purchase are the same flow, one tap apart.

What it structurally cannot do

Three things, and each follows from what the tool is built on.

Anything Sephora does not sell. Sephora's March 2017 release put its own assortment at 14,000 products across 200 curated brands. Virtual Artist can only paint a shade that exists inside Sephora's own catalogue. A product carried at a different retailer is not a shade the tool can reach, no matter how well it might suit you.

A coordinated whole look, built around you. The closest Virtual Artist gets is Expert Looks, a small set of full-face presets added alongside the 2017 eyeshadow update and overlaid on every face the same way. That solves coordination in one direction: someone thought about how the eye, cheek and lip worked together before you opened the app. Nothing in Sephora's own material describes a preset adjusting itself to the face wearing it, undertone included. Pick your own combination instead, a lipstick here and an eyeshadow there, and you are back to trying one product against an otherwise bare face, one region at a time.

A keepable image. Virtual Artist lets you capture what the live view shows you and send it on. What you save is a frame of a video overlay, carrying whatever your phone's camera decided about white balance and exposure at that exact second, rather than a picture made to represent the shade itself. Close the app and reopen it under different light, and the same shade reads differently on the same face.

Sephora Virtual Artist, by the numbers

What you're checkingSephora Virtual Artist
Launched2 February 2016, inside the Sephora to Go app
Built byModiFace, "developed exclusively for Sephora," per Sephora's own March 2017 release
Runs onLive camera, tracked on your own device
CatalogueSephora's own stock only. 14,000 products across 200 brands, per Sephora's 2017 release
What you can tryOne product at a time, plus a small set of preset Expert Looks
What you keepA screenshot or clip of the live overlay
Adds to basketYes, directly from the try-on screen
CostFree
Who owns the underlying tech nowL'Oréal, since its March 2018 acquisition of ModiFace

Read the last row twice. The engine Sephora describes as built exclusively for it now belongs to a company that also owns dozens of the brand houses competing for shelf space at Sephora.

Who built it, and where does your photo go

Who actually built Sephora Virtual Artist?

ModiFace. Sephora's own 2017 press release credits "technology developed exclusively for Sephora by ModiFace, a leader in facial visualization and skin analysis." L'Oréal acquired ModiFace in March 2018, folding the company that built Sephora's try-on engine into a group whose own brand portfolio includes Lancome, Urban Decay and Maybelline, brands Sephora stocks and competes against on its own shelves. What that acquisition changed inside the code Sephora runs today is not something either company has published, so this page states the acquisition and leaves the rest unclaimed.

Does Sephora Virtual Artist upload my photo anywhere?

Live try-on of this kind is typically processed on the device itself, tracking your face and painting the overlay locally rather than sending frames to a server, which matches how Sephora's own material describes the camera doing the work in real time. Sephora has not published which of its own systems see which images, so treat that as how the category usually behaves rather than a guarantee about Sephora's own servers. The colour-match tool sits apart from this: photographing a product to identify its shade is an image you are choosing to submit, and what happens to it afterward belongs to Sephora's own privacy policy rather than to how live try-on works.

Where Looksmith differs

Looksmith is not a faster version of Sephora Virtual Artist, and it is not trying to be. It is a different tool built for a different question, coming soon to iOS from Mirable Labs, Inc. You save a Looksmith Likeness once, a set of selfies that becomes your reusable face, and Looksmith renders a complete look across twelve regions onto your own photograph rather than one product against a bare face. What comes back is a Looksmith poster, a 9:16 image of your own photograph with the makeup painted into it, kept as a picture rather than caught as a frame of a live camera feed. Looksmith also keeps your own pose, head tilt and framing rather than pasting your face into a preset look, and it will not touch your face shape or your eyelids while doing any of that, by design rather than by accident.

None of that makes Looksmith the right tool for the question Virtual Artist already answers well, which is whether one specific product on Sephora's shelf suits you before you buy it there.

Is Sephora Virtual Artist free?

Yes. It is a built-in feature of the Sephora app, at no separate cost.

Can I use Looksmith yet?

Not yet. Looksmith has no App Store listing, and the site takes waitlist emails in the meantime. The first six Looksmith looks are free at onboarding, and after that Looksmith runs on credits bought in packs, with no subscription. Pricing is set at launch, so there is no figure to print here. More on who builds it is on the about page, and what happens to any photograph you send it is in the privacy policy.

Which one to actually open

If you are standing in front of a product page or an aisle, deciding between two shades Sephora already sells, open Virtual Artist. It is free, it is fast, and it ends in a basket rather than a decision you have to remember later. If the question is bigger than one product, whether a whole look works on you, and you want a picture to look at again tomorrow rather than a frame you had to catch mid-video, that is the job Virtual Artist was never built for. It shows you a shade. It does not show you a look, and it was never trying to.

Looksmith renders a full makeup look onto your own face and lists the products it used. iOS, coming soon.

What Looksmith does